Guest Post: Exploring lesbianism through Otherness in Cat People (1942)

Guest contributor: Bruna Foletto Lucas is passionate about films, especially horror films – a love she has grown to be proud of in spite of all of the eye rolls she has lived through. Her favourite films are Halloween, Scream and Cabaret. She has an MA in Film Studies by Kingston University, where she was able to go through a cathartic experience whilst writing her dissertation on women directors of horror films. Her writings can also be found on London Horror Society and UK Film Review. You can find her ranting on Twitter @Bruna_FinalGirl and posting nonsense stories on Instagram @foletto.b

——————-

clke9lhp0clikgszqwiphqesseyz5g_largeIn 1942, during the height of the monster horror films, Cat People was born. Directed by Jacques Tourneur and produced by none other than Val Lewton, the feature follows the story of Irena Dubrovna (Simone Simon), a Serbian immigrant living in New York City. We first meet Irena at a zoo, whilst she sketches a black panther. Alongside us, Oliver Reed (Kent Smith) also meets Irena and, just like us, falls in love with her. Irena is amenable; she plays along and eventually marries Oliver.

Newly wed, both Oliver and Irena start to slowly feel disappointed with their relationship. They still haven’t consummated the marriage and Irena falls into a depression that leads Oliver to find psychiatric help for her.

Irena is haunted by a legend that supports the story that after being enslaved by the Mameluks, Christian residents of her home village turned to witchcraft and Satan. King John of Serbia drives the Mameluks away and, after seeing what their people have become and have done, kills them. Some of them, however, are able to escape to the mountains⁠—the “wisest and most wicked”⁠—where Irena was born. Notwithstanding, the legend also says that should Irena engage in any sexual activity, she will become a cat person and kill everything and everyone on her way. Irena believes her past is tainted and, needless to say, everyone around her deems her anxieties as “silly”.

Before we start analysing the film, it is important to recognise the period in which the film was made. The Hays Code was still a very important factor in Hollywood, with all the DO’s and DON’Ts of producing a picture. One of the aspects they used to censor was sexuality; therefore, when films wanted to portray sex, they were driven to try different and more elaborate ways. Homosexuality was a big no-no, therefore any queer reading of films is done through its subtext. This analysis of Cat People will not be different.

cat-people-1942-featured

The Repressed and Irina as the ‘Other’

In psychoanalysis, as theorised by Freud and later explored by Robin Wood, there are two types of repression: the basic and the surplus. The basic is the universal and necessary repression individuals undergo in order to maintain a civilised society. Surplus repression originates from particular cultures and works in a way to make people habituated from infancy to take upon social roles in society, such as man as the provider and the source of power in a relationship, and woman as the dependent.

Wood expanded Freud’s concepts in Film Studies, focusing on the definition of uncanny. Freud explains the uncanny from the perspective of the impact on a person’s impressions of certain situations. It is something that is both familiar and unfamiliar, but it’s supposed to remain hidden from our consciousness, as our mind has previously surmounted them.

Finally, we explore the ‘Other’, which, as written by Wood, represents not only “something external to the culture or to the self, but also as what is repressed (though never destroyed) in the self and projected outward in order to be hated and disowned.” Moreover, he makes note that the real subject of horror is the emergence of these repressed feelings and our struggle to keep them hidden from normality. As a consequence, when the normality is disrupted by the appearance of a monster, it means that the repressed has returned.

cat-people-1942

Although she is the protagonist of the film, Irena is the Other. In simpler terms, she is an immigrant, she speaks with an accent, and she does not belong with Oliver. And, reading the subtext: Irena is not happy with Oliver even though she desperately wants to be⁠—she cries confessing how much she wants to be Mrs. Reed but cannot because of the “evil” inside of her. This evil is her homosexual tendencies that inhibit her from kissing Oliver and from having sex with him; if she does so, she will turn into a wild animal. Irina is crippled by her anxieties—she loves Oliver but she is unable to give him all of her.

Here, the concept of uncanny fits well as it explains something that is familiar, yet unknown to her. Irena feels different; she envies other women because they are “free,” yet she cannot put into words exactly what ails her.

During a scene where the newlywed couple and their friends are at a Serbian restaurant, two men spot a very beautiful woman, although her beauty causes some discomfort⁠— “she looks like a cat.” This woman fixates on Irena and walks up to her and calls her “my sister,” acknowledging that they both have a past or a bond that ties them together. Irena pulls away from that moment and hopes no one has noticed the palpable tension between the two women. Putting the film into context, this scene would resonate with any queer audience watching the film at the year it was released.

stalking

Irina as the Monster

Irena is doomed from the beginning. In horror films, especially via a psychological reading, the Other is the monster. In Cat People, this causes a problem: the monster is often killed, ostracised, and excluded from society by the protagonist, the hero. Here, our hero is the monster.

In a theory proposed by Noel Carroll, the role of the monster is dissected and the conclusion that Carroll arrives is that not only should the monster be dangerous, but it should also be “be threatening psychologically, morally, or socially.” By turning into a panther, Irina ticks the dangerous box. Psychologically, morally, and socially threatening… those boxes she ticks with queer subtext. Psychologically, she is spiralling into a paralysing depression that is also taking a toll on her marriage; morally, as she fights with her own urges; and socially, as she threatens normality⁠—the heterosexual couple. Thus, she is ‘impure’.

Irena’s otherness/monstrousness comes from her sexuality. Here, we can find another important element. Wood himself has noticed that horror films often repress women’s sexuality and punish those who defy the “wife/mother framework”. Therefore, Irina must be punished for defying the framework by refusing to be⁠—even if she is unable to be⁠—a good wife and a mother.

CAT PEOPLE (1942)

In order to belong in a patriarchal society, especially in the 1940s, women have to fulfil a certain role; they have to fit into the part they are meant to play, even if they need to change themselves. As Kristeva explains, in order to belong in society, women must reject themselves and lose their identity – “I expel myself, I spit myself out”. Finally, Irena rejects everything she is in order to fit in. Unfortunately for her, it is too late and Oliver files for a divorce. The divorce means much more to Irena than just the dissolution of a marriage. She has lost her compass⁠—her “excuse”⁠—she has no way to turn.

Having lost her place in society and feeling alone, she makes the conscious decision to accept a relationship with Dr Louis Judd, her psychologist. She knows very well what will happen if she engages in sexual activity with him, but she accepts it and chooses it, as for her death is better than a life of loneliness, which is what would end up happening to her if she acknowledged her truth. Therefore, she kisses Dr Judd knowing this is the end for her⁠—and finally the hero kills the Other.

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s